|
Post by LadyOfRohan on Feb 16, 2004 21:44:14 GMT
Most anti-arwen sites are bad, but there are some good ones! I forget where I saw it, but there was one that had "top ten reasons why this orc is better than arwen" and they were all true ;D! lol Anyway, I had to vote for Eowyn. She has always been my favorite character. And she was great killing the witchking! She's so brave! Even in the movie, the most brave thing arwen did was to draw her sword. No offence meant to the Arwen fans!
|
|
|
Post by Mirkgirl on Feb 17, 2004 19:26:45 GMT
hmm I don't think they're comparable. And it becomes even worse if we add movie and book versions... there always was something that bugged me in Eowyn tho, no offence to her fans... she has always been a symbol to "the woman CAN do anything but what she WANTS is a family"... and I KNOW it's true in most cases, still I don't like it. My usual answer to Arwen or Eowyn is Galadriel actually...
|
|
|
Post by Galadriel on Feb 19, 2004 0:58:34 GMT
I just can't deside ;D I really can't... I like them both v.much....
|
|
|
Post by Tishamet on Mar 30, 2004 3:40:49 GMT
I like Eowyn better. I might be a little biased, since Eowyn is my favorite character in all Middle-earth, but I think that she has much more of a developed character. Movie Eowyn in definitely better. Arwen in the movies is a tiny bit annoying, since for one reason, every time I watch FOTR, I'm thinking in the back of my mind "Glorfindel would have been better." Liv Tyler dod a great job, but they completely changed Arwen. In the books she was really wise and happy, and I don't think they did a very good job in the movies about getting the point across that ARWEN was the one who made Aragorn proclaim himself. There are a hundred other reasons why I don't like movie Arwen, but I won't go into them...
I liked book Arwen alot, but I think I still have to go with Eowyn here. Arwen is great as the beautiful and wise queen, but for one, she isn't in it very much, and also, Eowyn has so much more personality...
I'm gonna start another poll...Arwen or Galadriel
|
|